The moment when Chaney snatched away the mask from his famous Death’s Head also provided one of the great moments of screen history, (reportedly causing many people among the early audiences to faint!) as well as setting a standard for all who have since played the role. With that film, Chaney not only made himself an international star but placed the story of The Phantom of the Opera firmly alongside those other great horror classics, Dracula and Frankenstein.
Indeed, it is arguable that if Chaney, the Man of a Thousand Faces, had not starred in that hugely influential 1925 silent movie, Gaston Leroux’s story might well have remained in obscurity – as the original book most certainly has done for many years – instead of inspiring a whole series of screen and stage adaptations during the past half century. It is not just the figure of the mysterious music lover that haunts the story of The Phantom of the Opera but also that of the remarkable American film star, Lon Chaney Snr., for, more than anyone else, he created the image most readily associated in the public mind with the tale – that of the disfigured man skulking through the labyrinths of l’Opéra masterminding the career of his beautiful protégée.
Make no attempt to see her again.Prior to the 2004 movie version of The Phantom of the Opera, directed by Joel Schumacher and starring Gerard Butler and Emmy Rossum, the Phantom has undergone several screen adaptions. The Angel of Music has her under his wing. The costumes are intricate and stunning looking, as are the sets, hairstyling, and decorations. The opera house is grandiose and impressive. The way the Phantom's lair looks is haunting and beautiful. "The Phantom of the Opera" also provides elegant, sumptuous, and striking visual eye-candy given that it takes place in the 1800s. Patrick Wilson is no slouch, either, and is a surprisingly good vocalist. She has a magnificent voice and really belts out her part and gives it all she's got. It doesn't hurt that they are being sung by Emmy Rossum, who is fantastic as Christine. The source material is so strong and the music is so compelling and powerful that we're able to forgive most of its other flaws (except the damn slow motion because it's truly out of place and terrible). Andrew Lloyd Webbers' songs and melodies are timeless and iconic, and we can't help but sing along with the movie every single time we watch it. All that aside, we really, really like this film.
Needless to say, some artistic license was taken to dramatize the story. Truth be told, we could have used more horses. Hello, have you seen Pierce Brosnan in "Mamma Mia!"? There are also some odd directorial choices by Joel Schumacher, including an excessive, unnecessary use of slow motion and a scene where a horse appears out of nowhere. There is some truth to that critique, but we think he has a commanding, intense on-screen presence, and honestly, he does a decent enough job considering his total lack of singing experience. One could argue that Gerard Butler is undoubtedly miscast as the Phantom since he lacks the musical chops to really pull off the role. Let us say off the bat that this version of "The Phantom of the Opera" is not without its flaws. "What you heard was a dream and nothing more. When Christine's childhood friend Raoul (Patrick Wilson) returns and garners her affections, it causes the Phantom to lash out, putting everyone in danger since he wants her all to himself. The Phantom uses fear and threats of death and destruction to establish Christine at the forefront where he knows she belongs. Christine quickly becomes a star after she proves her musical talents to new theater managers Firmin (Ciarán Hinds) and André (Simon Callow). He believes she should be the lead singer at the opera house instead of Carlotta (Minnie Driver). Christine is very talented, and the Phantom has taken a fancy to her. Schumacher is a veteran director known for such films as the teen horror "The Lost Boys," the racial-driven courtroom drama "A Time to Kill," and the incomparably campy "Batman and Robin." This film revolves around a young singer named Christine Daaé (Emmy Rossum), who is taken under the wing of and trained by a disfigured musical genius who lives in the catacombs under a Parisian opera house and haunts the building as a 'Phantom' (Gerard Butler). Just shy of a century after the original publication and 18 years after Webber adapted it to a musical, writer/director Joel Schumacher brings that story to the silver screen. That adaptation has helped keep the story alive. Gaston Leroux's novel has been adapted and reimagined countless times, but none caught the imagination of the public quite like Andrew Lloyd Webber's 1986 musical. "The Phantom of the Opera" is a story that dates back to the first decade of the 20th century.